West Bengal moves SC against Calcutta HC restraint on KMC polls under revised ward delimitation

New Delhi, Nov. 16: The West Bengal government has moved the Supreme Court challenging a Calcutta High Court order restraining the State Election Commission from notifying elections to the Kolkata Municipal Corporation on the basis of a September delimitation exercise that proposes to increase the number of civic wards from 144 to 209.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya and Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee had on November 6 directed that no election notification be issued on the basis of the amended Schedule II of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation Act, 1980, until a pending challenge to the delimitation exercise is decided.

The High Court was hearing an appeal filed by former councillor Dipu Das, who had questioned the validity of the September 11 notification redrawing municipal ward boundaries ahead of the civic elections.

The principal issue before the High Court was whether an administrator appointed by the State government after dissolution of the elected Corporation could recommend alteration of municipal ward boundaries under Section 601 of the KMC Act.

The High Court held that the statutory power to make such a recommendation vested in the Corporation as an elected body and could not be exercised by an administrator entrusted only with temporary administrative functions.

It observed that permitting the administrator to make the recommendation would, in effect, enable the State government to make a recommendation to itself through its own appointee.

The court also considered whether Article 243ZG of the Constitution, which limits judicial interference in certain municipal electoral matters, barred the challenge.

It held that the constitutional restriction did not apply to the exercise under consideration since the dispute concerned an executive notification issued under Section 601 of the KMC Act.

Das had also alleged that the delimitation exercise amounted to gerrymandering intended to confer political advantage and that it was based on electoral rolls instead of actual population figures.

The High Court said allegations of malice in law and gerrymandering required adjudication and could not be finally determined at the interim stage, though it expressed concern over the sequence of events leading to the notification.

It consequently modified the single-judge order and restrained the State Election Commission from proceeding with elections on the basis of the revised ward boundaries until disposal of the petition.

Share it :