
“Khīñcho na kamānoñ ko na talvār nikālo,
Jab top muqābil ho to aḳhbār nikālo.”
(Do not draw your bows, nor take out your swords; when faced with cannons, bring out the newspapers.)
— Akbar AllahabadiMore than a century ago, poet Akbar Allahabadi envisioned the newspaper as a fearless shield against tyranny—a pen mightier than artillery. Yet as India observes National Press Day on November 16, a date established to commemorate the founding of the Press Council of India and uphold ethical journalism, the country confronts a sobering inversion of that ideal. Rather than holding power to account, vast segments of India’s mainstream media have surrendered to corporate, commercial, and political interests, transforming the Fourth Estate from democracy’s guardian into one of its gravest threats.
Prime-Time Theatre and the Cost of Distraction
The erosion of journalistic rigor was laid bare on May 7, 2025, in the aftermath of the Pahalgam terror attack. Instead of pursuing verified facts, prime-time television descended into jingoistic spectacle. Channels competed to broadcast unsubstantiated claims—of Indian forces entering Islamabad, phantom strikes on Karachi, and fabricated surrenders by foreign leaders—without a shred of official corroboration.
This theatrics did not inform the public; it inflamed passions while conveniently shielding authorities from scrutiny. By manufacturing a war-room frenzy, broadcasts deflected urgent questions regarding the intelligence and security lapses that cost 26 lives in a high-security zone. Far from an isolated lapse, this pattern has defined coverage of major flashpoints in recent years, from Pulwama and the 2020 Delhi violence to the farmers’ protests and border standoffs with China.
Manufacturing Consensus Through Misinformation
Beneath episodic sensationalism lies a deeper institutional shift: the systematic replacement of reporting with narrative management. Legitimate domestic grievances—such as unemployment protests in Jammu—are routinely delegitimised through insinuations of foreign funding rather than examined as pressing socioeconomic crises. Meanwhile, a steady stream of unverified security alerts crowds out accountability on governance failures. A frightened, distracted citizenry is far easier to steer than an informed one, turning misinformation into an instrument for manufacturing public compliance.
The Criminalisation of Dissent
Equally alarming is the role of broadcast media in branding dissent as treason. When historian Professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad was arrested on contentious charges of sedition, mainstream studios bypassed due process in favour of orchestrated character assassination. Scholars, activists, and minority voices are routinely cast as “internal threats” in television trials that substitute ideological policing for reasoned debate.
The fallout extends well beyond television screens. In districts such as Bijnor, local authorities have linked spikes in communal tension to inflammatory broadcasts—a stark reminder that rhetoric amplified in studios carries real-world consequences on the ground.
Corporate Consolidation, Digital Policing, and Border Gatekeeping
The roots of this crisis are fundamentally structural. Media ownership in India is increasingly concentrated within sprawling corporate conglomerates whose political alignments heavily influence newsroom priorities, while heavy financial reliance on government advertising discourages critical reporting. While television relies on volume and spectacle, print journalism often exercises power through omission—sanitising reality by downplaying economic distress, minimising mass movements, or sidestepping robust editorial stances on digital surveillance and censorship despite warnings from international watchdogs and the Editors Guild of India.
Over the past year, the architecture of information control has tightened even further through administrative and digital instruments. Mechanisms such as the government’s Sahyog portal—backed by recent amendments to information technology rules requiring online platforms to comply with official content takedown orders within three hours—have created rapid-response machinery for scrubbing critical journalism and dissent from the internet.
This intolerance for scrutiny has increasingly extended to international observers as well. Just days before National Press Day, ahead of the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad, more than a hundred cleared foreign delegates and speakers were abruptly barred from entering the country after their visas were revoked at the eleventh hour. Among those turned away was Norwegian independent journalist Helle Lyng Svendsen, who had been scheduled to speak on a panel examining the future of media and press freedom—and who had previously questioned the Prime Minister during an overseas visit over his refusal to take unscripted questions from the press. Dismissing the controversy as a routine exercise of sovereign discretion, authorities reinforced a clear message: critical questioning is unwelcome not only in domestic studios, but at the nation’s borders as well.
Global Standing and Independent Outposts
The cumulative impact of legal harassment, digital censorship, and gatekeeping is reflected in India’s continued slide on the World Press Freedom Index, falling six places in 2026 to 157 out of 180 countries—placing the world’s largest democracy firmly in the “very serious” category alongside authoritarian regimes. The invocation of stringent national security and criminal statutes—from the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) to sedition provisions under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita—alongside raids, lawsuits, severe reporting restrictions in regions like Kashmir and the Northeast, and coordinated online harassment, has steadily narrowed the space for investigative reporting.
Yet pockets of resilience persist. Independent digital platforms and journalist-led channels—including Newslaundry, The Wire, Scroll, The Quint, The Caravan, HW News, Satya Hindi, Public India, and individual commentators such as Ravish Kumar, Ajit Anjum, and Dhruv Rathee—continue to pursue public-interest journalism despite financial pressure, state scrutiny, and cyberattacks. Sustained largely by direct audience subscriptions rather than state patronage, their survival underscores a continuing public appetite for credible reporting.
A Reckoning for Citizens
When a press echoes only what the powerful wish to hear, it ceases to protect the republic and begins to dismantle it—forging consent, deepening social fractures, and insulating the elite from accountability.
National Press Day cannot be reduced to ceremonial platitudes or newly revised codes of conduct. Reclaiming the spirit of Allahabadi’s couplet requires active civic intervention: citizens must withdraw attention from sensationalist outlets, demand editorial accountability, and financially sustain independent journalism. The health of Indian democracy depends on whether truth is defended as a public right—or allowed to be recast as treason.
~Hasnain Naqvi is a former member of the history faculty at St. Xavier’s College, Mumbai….
The opinions expressed here are solely those of the author.